The Examined: Beauty Industry Faces Regulatory Makeover
As the calendar turned to 2023, the cosmetics world was at the threshold of a new regulatory landscape. On December 30th, 2022, President Biden’s signature on a hefty omnibus spending bill ushered in a transformative era for beauty industry oversight. Buried deep within the 4,155-page document was the Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act of 2022, a provision to redefine the relationship between beauty brands and federal regulators.
This legislative milestone grants the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) unprecedented authority over the cosmetics sector, marking a long-awaited update to industry rules. Lindsay Dahl, chief Impact Officer at Vitamin Brand Ritual, hailed the act as a “meaningful step forward” with “real substantial policies” that promise to alter both production methods and consumer exposure to certain chemicals. While celebrating this progress, Dahl emphasized the need for continued efforts to ensure comprehensive safety measures for cosmetics users.
The new law introduces several critical changes to the regulatory landscape. Perhaps most significantly, it empowers the FDA to issue mandatory recalls for unsafe products, a tool previously unavailable in cosmetics. Additionally, the FDA will establish rules for companies to disclose fragrance allergens, addressing a persistent concern in the industry.
Other provisions include mandatory registration for domestic and foreign beauty product manufacturers within a year of the law’s enactment. This measure aims to enhance the FDA’s ability to manage recalls and investigate potential issues. The agency is also charged with developing good manufacturing practices for cosmetics, mirroring standards already in place for over-the-counter drugs like sunscreens and dandruff shampoos.
The legislation directs the FDA to investigate the safety of PFAS chemicals, often dubbed “forever chemicals” due to their persistence in biological systems and the environment. These substances, valued for repelling water, oil, and heat, have come under increasing scrutiny in recent years.
Another focus area is the standardization of asbestos testing in talc, a response to ongoing controversies surrounding talc-based products and their potential health risks. The law also mandates a study on chemical hair straighteners, following research suggesting a link to uterine cancer, with particular concern for Black women who are disproportionately affected.
While the new regulations represent a significant step forward, some industry experts note that many responsible US manufacturers were already adhering to similar standards. Kelly Dobos, a cosmetic chemist and former president of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists, suggests that the law’s most substantial impact may be on smaller, independent brands, particularly those working with overseas manufacturers.
For “clean” beauty brands, the new regulations may not require significant changes, as many already comply with stringent standards set by retailers or self-imposed guidelines. The Credo Clean Standard, for instance, maintains requirements that surpass the new law’s stipulations. However, the legislation is a positive move that codifies and strengthens existing best practices.
It’s worth noting that the law does not directly ban or restrict specific ingredients or mandate supply chain transparency. Critics point out that it also lacks provisions specifically addressing the concerns of BIPOC consumers or the products they frequently use.
Despite these limitations, industry insiders view the act as a signal toward a cleaner future for cosmetics. Raising the regulatory bar encourages the entire sector to move in a more responsible direction. While not explicitly driving innovation, the new law is expected to elevate standards across the board, potentially inspiring further product safety and quality advancements.
Consumers can anticipate greater oversight and potentially safer products as the beauty industry adapts to these new regulations. However, the true impact of this legislative shift will only become clear as implementation unfolds in the coming years.
The Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act of 2022 marks the beginning of a new chapter in beauty industry governance, promising a future where regulatory standards and consumer safety take center stage. It signals to the industry that the bar for safety and transparency has been raised, encouraging a shift towards cleaner practices and formulations.
While the law doesn’t mandate innovation directly, it creates an environment where responsible practices are encouraged and required. This could lead to new, safer product formulations and manufacturing processes as companies strive to meet and exceed the latest standards.
As the dust settles on this legislative change, all eyes will be on how the beauty industry rises to meet these new challenges and opportunities. The coming years will likely see a period of adjustment and adaptation as companies big and small navigate the new regulatory landscape, potentially reshaping the market in the process.
Ultimately, this regulatory overhaul represents a significant milestone in the ongoing dialogue between government, industry, and consumers about the safety and transparency of cosmetic products. It’s a step towards a future where beauty isn’t just skin deep but grounded in rigorous safety standards and consumer trust.
